Nature or nurture the age old question.
Personally, I don’t think there is any question at all. It’s clearly nurture.
I think at birth we are all a rough hewn piece of wood like a log. Within that wood is the potential for many things but it also has some structure inside. This structure is genetic. As time goes on many things take chunks out of the wood. A bad experience in the water, a good experience on holiday, a death, a good teacher, a bad teacher, other good and bad influences in our lives, all these and more make changes to the basic wood and each make their impact on that persons personality. Good or bad, sometimes a bit of both. Sometimes the structure in the wood changes the cut that an individual is making and unintentional changes are made. The structure makes some people just unable to handle numbers, have word salad, vivid imaginations, short tempers, weak muscles, etc. There are many different structures in the wood and very little you can do to modify them although these structures can actually work out to be positive if the rest of the wood is cut well. As an example a structured mind can be a benefit to a Sherlock Holmes or a Moriarty. A steady hand to an assassin or a surgeon. Same skill but different morals and intentions.
I believe that most of us do not realise our potentials because we have the wrong teachers, parents or environment to bring out the best from us. Imagine if Michelangelo had not been given the opportunity to practise painting. We may never have heard of him. What about if Gordo had been educated by a decent maths teacher and had a father figure who had a bit of joy in him. It’s unfortunate but its life and all of us have unrealised potential because of our upbringing and circumstances.
Now regarding the statement I made in an earlier post that killers are born not made. We all have a bit of killer in us. It’s part of our sense of survival. However most of us never have to use it. Again imagine Michelangelo not painting. An unrealised potential. Then when a situation arises a person can quickly discover they can kill and they are good at it. Training can also bring out the potential but like everything else if there is no latent skill then there is no potential to unleash.
Everyone has potential. Everyone has capabilities just waiting to be discovered. That is what makes the screwup with education in our countries so sad. How many Michelangelo’s have passed through a pretty uneventful life because they didn’t have the chance to practise art? How many potential Einsteins, Newtons, Franklins, Dickens, Adam Smiths, Tom Paines, etc. etc. have we lost because of our Disney education systems?
On the plus side. How many Dahmers, Mansons, Gordos, Mansons, etc. have been averted by the right people giving them guidance and leading them down different paths?
We all have the potential in each of us to change the world. Let’s not waste it.
Better than life
In the Sci-Fi series ‘Gateway‘ by Frederik Pohl the main character had access to a AI VR system that could stand in for him for phone calls and virtual meetings. It had sufficient knowledge of his requirements and how he thought so he could be in many places at once and in communication with several people at once. (and that is before he dies and becomes a multitasking computer program but that’s another story.)
So when I read about this project called LifeLike I could see that they are looking at creating a similar program and that they are right at the start of the project. I see the visual component coming on in leaps and bounds a bit like the special effects in films where they can actually replace actors like they have done with Oliver Reed where when he died whilst in the middle of filming he was replaced by a computer generated image in Gladiator.
I’m also fairly confident that they can generate a computer program that thinks like me 95% of the time and can respond to certain stimuli. Something I could use when chatting on IMs to people about low profile stuff where I could be called to help when it got a bit deep. What I’m not convinced about is they can create one for business use. One that would last five minutes in a business like environment without getting me fired and summarily executed.
I still think we are decades and several generations of hardware away from that sort of AI but we are woring towards it. To be honest it’s also an area I would love to be involved with as AI is one of my interests and things have moved on significantly from when I was looking at it with programs like LISP just to provide chat based systems that provided basic AI functionality.